If one thing appears too good to be true, it most likely is. French insurance coverage shared Covea will not continue having its buy of reinsurer PartnerRe after attempts to renegotiate collapsed. The original price of $9bn agreed with Agnelli household holding organization Exor seemed nice in March. Doubt throughout the measurements of the insurance coverage liability from pandemic means it is now out of the question. Yet shutting the doorway on PartnerRe makes Covea chief executive Thierry Derez with minimal alternatives for the transformational offer he seeks.

Scarcity value helps give an explanation for 1.3 times guide worth originally supplied when it comes to Bermuda based reinsurer, a one-fifth advanced to detailed rivals such as for example Swiss Re. Struck by the marketplace sell-off that occurred right after terms were concurred, reinsurers now exchange well below book worth.

although a fresh package was struck at guide value, which dropped 9 percent for PartnerRe in the first quarter, the price tag precipitates to about $6bn.That is significantly less than Exor paid to acquire PartnerRe in 2016. Little shock after that that manager John Elkann is willing to allow package collapse.

It could be the second successive quote to fail recently for Thierry Derez and Covea. a dangerous attempt to get French reinsure Scor had been rebuffed in 2018, causing accusations of underhanded strategies and ongoing litigation from Scor. Mr Derez though may again direct his focus back again to their Parisian neighbour. Scor investors had been thrilled to part with leader Dennis Kessler in rebuffing Coveas original method. Losings due to the pandemic could see them matter that respect if Covea had been to test once more.

Scor is in-line for considerable losings after its contact with United States life insurance coverage. In a worst-case situation, the obligation could possibly be over 1.5bn believe Jefferies. That may begin to see the dividend suspended and stocks which are currently down 40 per cent this season pushed also reduced. The opportunity to settle an old score together with his local competitor are too-good to Mr Derez to overlook.

Lex advises the FTs Due Diligence publication, a curated briefing from the realm of mergers and purchases. Just click here to sign up.

Letter in reaction to the column:

Covid-19 risks have to be noticed in an effective framework / From Romain Launay, Group Chief Operating Officer, Scor, Paris, France